Why Does Brand Search Lose Credit in Total Impact (TI), or Why Might Another Channel Get More Credit Than Expected?
Summary
In the Total Impact (TI) attribution model, brand search often receives less credit than expected because it is typically not a prospecting source. Instead, credit is redistributed to top-of-funnel (TOF) channels like Meta and TikTok, which play a larger role in generating new customer demand.
Why This Happens
-
Brand Search Captures Demand, Doesn't Create It
- Customers searching for your brand are likely already aware of it due to earlier interactions.
- TI prioritizes credit for prospecting channels that drive new customer interest.
-
Reallocation to TOF Channels
- Meta, TikTok, and other TOF sources introduce customers to your brand.
- TI shifts credit to these channels when they contribute to the purchase journey.
-
Click-Based & Survey Data Influence Attribution
- TI incorporates click-based and post-purchase survey (PPS) data.
- If survey responses favor a TOF channel (e.g., "I found you through TikTok"), TI increases its credit accordingly.
Example Scenario
- A customer sees a TikTok ad but does not click.
- Later, they search for your brand on Google and make a purchase.
- Traditional models give full credit to Google Ads.
- TI recognizes the initial TikTok exposure and reallocates some credit to TikTok.
How This Affects Reporting
-
Brand Search May Appear Weaker
- Google Ads may show lower attributed revenue in TI than in last-click models.
- This doesn’t mean Google Ads is ineffective—it reflects a shift in attribution logic.
-
Prospecting Channels Gain More Credit
- TOF channels like Meta and TikTok may show higher revenue than in last-click models.
- This better represents their role in generating new demand.
-
More Holistic Attribution Insights
- TI provides a more accurate picture of marketing performance by balancing click data and survey responses.
How to Interpret the Data Correctly
-
Compare Across Attribution Models
- Last-click will heavily favor Google Search.
- TI distributes credit more evenly, accounting for demand creation.
-
Understand the Role of TOF Channels
- Expect Meta, TikTok, and other TOF sources to gain credit in TI.
- Recognize their influence on later purchase behaviors.
-
Use TI for a Full-Funnel View
- TI is not meant to match last-click attribution but to show the real impact of each channel.
- Use it to optimize spend across the entire customer acquisition journey.
By understanding how TI shifts credit from demand-capturing sources like brand search to prospecting channels that create demand, you can better interpret attribution results and make more informed marketing decisions.
Updated 5 days ago